New York City Public Advocate Jumaane Williams posted a strong reaction to the Michigan attack, emphasizing that the synagogue has an early childcare center and school. 

"We must protect all our communities, from West Bloomfield Township to NYC, from violent hatred," Williams wrote in a statement.

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul described the Michigan incident as "a cowardly act of antisemitic violence."

"Our Jewish neighbors should never have to fear worshiping in peace," Hochul wrote on social media. "[New York State Police] will continue increased patrols at religious sites across the state."

A similar attack occurred Jan. 28, in New York City, where suspect Dan Sohail allegedly repeatedly rammed his vehicle into the headquarters of Chabad Lubavitch Headquarters in Brooklyn, New York.

When Sohail arrived at the side entrance of the building, he allegedly moved protection barriers, moved congregants out of the way, and drove his car into the building’s side entrance four times.

While the doors were damaged, no injuries were reported.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who opposes the ongoing military strikes against Iran, described the Michigan shooting as "horrifying" on Thursday, adding his "thoughts are with the congregation and all who are shaken by this act of antisemitic violence."

"I am continuing to closely monitor the situation," Mamdani wrote in a dueling protests near Gracie Mansion, Mamdani's official residence, and the mayor was criticized for his response.

An 18-year-old counter-protester named Emir Balat was arrested for allegedly lighting and throwing suspected explosive devices at a small group demonstrating against "public Muslim prayer."

Following an initial escalation where a protester, affiliated with pardoned Jan. 6 rioter Jake Lang, used pepper spray, Balat threw an ignited device in the group's direction. Balat then retrieved a second device from a 19-year-old identified as Ibrahim Nikk, lit it, and dropped it near NYPD officers as he attempted to flee.

The NYPD bomb squad examined the items, which were described as tape-wrapped jars containing nuts, bolts, screws and hobby fuses. No injuries were reported.

Following the New York City attack, Mamdani released a statement labeling Lang a "white supremacist," alleging the protest was "rooted in bigotry and racism."

He later went on to address the men accused of throwing homemade bombs, saying "violence at a protest is never acceptable."

Former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo fired back at Mamdani's response, claiming that while he believes Lang "is a far right extremist," the bombs thrown by counter-protesters "literally would've done horrific damage."

"The mayor puts out a statement condemning Jake Lang. I agree," Cuomo said. "The second part of the statement condemns the terrorists. There is no moral equivalency. Jake Lang, bigot, hateful, of course. Yes, I agree. Terrorists who bring a bomb to kill people — they are not equivalent. This city has no tolerance for terrorism or attempted terrorists, and that statement has to be made loud and clear. There's a passivity. I didn't think we handled the attacks on the NYPD correctly."