An Israeli-Russian researcher held hostage for 903 days by an Iran-backed Iraqi terrorist group revealed to Fox News Digital that she spent the first four and a half months of her captivity inside the very militia stronghold Iraq's Trump-backed prime minister has now ordered the army to reclaim.

Elizabeth Tsurkov, a senior nonresident fellow at the New Lines Institute for Strategy and Policy, said Kata’ib Hezbollah turned a private family's home in Jurf al-Sakhr, south of Baghdad, into a prison where she was held captive.

"This is where I was held for 4.5 months," Tsurkov told Fox News Digital in an interview, referring to the early months of her captivity, which began with her abduction in Baghdad in March 2023. "I was held in a private home of a family that was taken over by Kata’ib Hezbollah and turned into a prison," she said.

Tsurkov, who was with Iran, she said, giving it opportunities to replenish its weapons even if it loses control of Jurf al-Sakhr.

Michael Knights, head of research at Horizon Engage, a New York-based strategic consultancy, and an adjunct fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, expressed skepticism that Baghdad would fundamentally challenge the militias.

"It's going to be very difficult to tell the difference between a real crackdown on Iran-backed militias and a fake one," Knights told Fox News Digital.

Previous Iraqi governments have announced crackdowns on militias, only for detainees to be released or armed groups to retain control through rebranded security arrangements.

In June 2020, when then-Prime Minister Mustafa al-Kadhimi ordered the arrest of 14 Kata’ib Hezbollah members. Armed militia supporters subsequently descended on Baghdad's fortified International Zone demanding their release. Most were later released, according to aexplosive-drone attack targeting his residence.fighting against ISIS ended, attracted by government-funded salaries and relatively secure employment. "They're not interested in dying in the service of the Iranian regime," she said of many rank-and-file fighters.

She distinguished those recruits from a smaller core of ideologically committed and better-trained operatives that Iran can mobilize for sophisticated military attacks.

That distinction, she said, could offer Baghdad a path toward reducing militia power without a full-scale confrontation. She proposed allowing some fighters to join the regular Iraqi army under independent military commanders, providing alternative employment while dismantling their existing command structures.

According to Knights, the current crackdown primarily affects the more confrontational Abu Hussein wing of Kata’ib Hezbollah, while another faction associated with senior militia commander Abu Fadak remains largely untouched. He argued that both ultimately remain responsive to Tehran.

Knights also questioned whether disrupting one oil-smuggling operation would substantially weaken the group's finances, citing its extensive investments in hotels, property and other commercial ventures.

But perhaps the clearest illustration of the contradictions facing Iraq's government, Knights said, lies in recent senior political appointments and Iran's choice of its next diplomatic representative in Baghdad.

On Oct. 15, Iraq's parliament approved Laith al-Khazali, a senior figure in the Iran-backed Asa’ib Ahl al-Haq militia, as one of three deputy prime ministers. The United States designated him and his brother Qais al-Khazali, the militia's leader, as specially designated global terrorists in 2020. Washington has accused the organization of carrying out attacks against American and coalition forces, according to al-Monitor.

Another newly appointed deputy prime minister, Muhsin al-Mandalawi, is the brother of two Iraqi businessmen sanctioned by the U.S. Treasury Department on Sept. 10 for facilitating financial transactions benefiting Iran. Knights also pointed to Iran's reported selection of Abdolreza Meskarian, a senior commander in the Revolutionary Guards' Quds Force, as its next ambassador to Iraq.

Tsurkov agreed that an operation intended merely to satisfy Washington could be exposed if displaced families remained unable to return.

The broader disarmament deadline, already extended until June 2027, was "utterly unrealistic," she said, arguing that Iraqi security institutions would require years of reform before they could reliably confront the militias.

"I tend to think it will not be real," she said of the current operation, while acknowledging that successful government control could represent a meaningful breakthrough.

For the former hostage, the ultimate measure of success is straightforward: whether Iraq's military merely enters the area, or whether the territory truly returns to civilian control.

"It's either the state is there, and people can return or not," she said.

Knights also remains skeptical that the current operation will deliver lasting results, suggesting Baghdad may reach a deal that allows the government to claim victory without substantially weakening Kata’ib Hezbollah. Still, he acknowledged the possibility that the confrontation could mark the beginning of a broader effort, even if he doubts this particular operation will prove decisive. "Every great journey starts with the first step," he said.