State Senate Passes Theis Bill To Add Voter ID Requirements
June 17, 2021
By David Eggert - The Associated Press
Republicans who control the Michigan Senate passed contentious legislation Wednesday sponsored by a local lawmaker that would mandate a photo ID to vote in person and add identity requirements for people who want to vote by mail.
The bills, which were sent to the GOP-led House on party-line 19-16 votes, are among a wave of Republican-sponsored measures to tighten voting rules in various states. Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer will veto the bills if they reach her desk, but the GOP could eventually sidestep her with a maneuver that lets the Legislature enact citizen-initiated ballot proposals.
Michigan voters without a photo ID now can sign an affidavit and cast a ballot at their polling place. More than 11,400 of nearly 5.6 million voters did that in the November election. Under the legislation, they would instead vote a provisional ballot and have to either verify their voter registration or their identity and residence within six days for it to count.
Voters currently seeking an absentee ballot by mail or at an election clerk’s office must sign the application, and the signature is matched to the voter file. The legislation, sponsored by Republican State Senator Lana Theis of Brighton Township, would require applicants to include a copy of their photo ID, their driver’s license number or the last four digits of their Social Security number. Those who do not would get a provisional ballot.
Republicans said the bills would ensure election integrity and security, contending the system became more vulnerable following a 2018 voter-approved constitutional amendment that expanded absentee voting and allowed same-day registration. Nearly 3.3 million people — a record — voted absentee in November amid the coronavirus pandemic.
Democrats denounced the legislation, which is opposed by clerks and voting-rights advocates, as a “poll tax” and said it would suppress the vote by making it harder to participate, particularly for seniors and low-income residents. They also raised identity theft concerns. The bills seek to address nonexistent problems amid former President Donald Trump’s false claims that he won, they said.
Trump’s allegations have been resoundingly rejected by state officials who certified the results, judges who dismissed multiple lawsuits filed by Trump and his allies, and a coalition of federal and state officials who called the 2020 election the “most secure” in U.S. history.
“Trump lost. You believed the big lie, engaged in treason at the U.S. Capitol. And now you want to change the rules because you realize that the demographics of America are changing and your base is out of control,” said Sen. Sylvia Santana, a Detroit Democrat who is Black. “So now you want to change the rules and add barriers so that people who look like me get frustrated and decide not to vote.”
GOP senators, including Theis, argued that Michigan’s photo ID law is insufficient due to the 2018 voting changes and noted that identification is required for many activities. They said voters previously were seen in person at least once, either when they registered to vote or when they voted for the first time, but now can register and vote by mail without showing ID.
Theis said Democrats were engaging in "scare tactics" and denied it created a personal security risk. “It’s not voter suppression. It’s not an undue burden. As a matter of fact, across the globe, ID is required to vote."
“These bills would help ensure the security and fairness of our elections,” said Sen. Ruth Johnson, a Holly Republican and former secretary of state. “Requiring voters to verify their identity with ID is the best way to protect the one-person, one-vote standard.”
The $10 fee for a state ID card already is waived for certain people, including the elderly, those on welfare or disability assistance, the homeless and veterans, she said. GOP senators on Wednesday introduced bills they said would remove all financial barriers to getting a card.
Michigan’s existing voter ID requirement was first enacted in 1996, declared unconstitutional by a Democratic state attorney general in 1997, reenacted in 2005 and upheld by the state Supreme Court in 2007.
A Senate committee is considering three-dozen other election bills. They would shut ballot drop boxes three hours before polls close, prohibit mass mailings of unsolicited ballot applications and ban prepaid postage on return envelopes.
It was not clear how soon the House will consider the three Senate-passed bills. It is scheduled to start a summer break in three weeks.
WHMI's Jon King contributed to this report.